They are separated by a cat’s whisker of a margin.
And anyone hoping for a resolution of the closest gubernatorial election in four decades will likely be disappointed.
As of 9:56 a.m., Gov. Phil Murphy was leading Republican challenger Jack Ciattarelli by just 1,408 votes after a pause in voting at 3 a.m. that saw Ciattarelli up front by 1,193 vote. But 158 of the state’s 6,348 voting districts had still not been counted.
In Union County, for example — one of the state’s largest counties that votes heavily Democratic — 95% of the votes had been counted and reported in the governor’s election as of 11:23 p.m. Tuesday. But the county clerk’s office stopped counting votes at that time.
Before the vote count was halted there, Murphy had a sizable lead over Ciattarelli in Union County, with 76,737 votes reported for the incumbent Democrat and 48,502 votes reported for the Republican challenger.
At the same time across the state, not all counties have included early voting results in the vote tallies that have been reported, nor have some included vote-by-mail counts. In fact, clerks can accept ballots postmarked by Election Day until Nov. 8.
In Ocean County, which came out strong for Ciatarrelli, the outstanding votes remaining include the last batch of vote by mail ballots placed in drop box locations on Tuesday, as well as vote-by-mail ballots that come to the board of elections between now and Monday. The vote by mail ballots postmarked as of Tuesday and placed in drop box locations by 8 p.m. that night will be counted immediately, said County Clerk Scott Colabella.
“We may do an update today, it depends how far they get with processing those,” he said.
Provisional ballots everywhere, meanwhile, have yet to be opened. Counties can’t start counting the paper provisional ballots cast by voters who come to the polls until the last mail-in ballot is counted.
On top of the outstanding ballots, there is the almost certain expectation by both camps to call for a recount.
New Jersey does not have an automatic recount law, but the candidates — or interested groups — may request one. A recount request is triggered by the filing of a suit in state Superior Court in the counties within 17 days of Election Day.
All of that means that a winner will probably not be declared anytime soon.
Both candidates early Wednesday morning acknowledged a long road ahead.
In a brief speech just after midnight, Murphy told supporters in Asbury Park, “We’re gonna wait for every vote to be counted. That’s how our democracy works.”
Ciattarelli, a former member of the state Assembly, told supporters in Bridgewater he had prepared “one hell of a victory speech,” but noted they were winning. Noting the time it will take to process the provisional and vote-by-mail tallies, he also voiced patience before he could declare they had won. “We want every legal vote to be counted,” he said.
Ben Dworkin, director of Rowan University’s Institute for Public Policy and Citizenship, said it could take upward of a week to resolve the election, and even longer if there is a recount.
That’s what happened in 1981, when Democrat Jim Florio and Republican Tom Kean remained in a deadlock for nearly a month, before Kean finally emerged as the winner. It took 27 days.
“We have to understand that these things don’t get resolved on election night anymore. It continues when until all the votes are counted,” said Dworkin, voting the early voting and absentee ballots that are now hallmarks of the election. “It’s no longer an Election Day it’s an election season and we have to get used to that.”
The immediate attention today will be to collect all the ballots, Dworkin said.
“The counting continues,” he said. “Despite failings and glitches, nobody is contesting that this was stolen. That’s not what these guys are talking about.”
Our journalism needs your support. Please subscribe today to NJ.com.