“They lost, and now they want to change the rules to give themselves a competitive advantage,” said House Minority Leader James Beverly, a Democrat from Macon. “The pendulum swings, and people can see through this foolishness in the truest sense of suppression and disenfranchisement.”
Republicans say they need to protect election integrity from the possibility of cheating. Some of the legislators seeking to limit absentee voting also signed onto a brief filed with the U.S. Supreme Court supporting the state of Texas’ failed lawsuit to overturn Georgia’s election results.
State Sen. Burt Jones, a Republican from Jackson, said in-person voting is safer than depositing ballots in the mail or drop boxes.
“When you don’t have a secure chain of custody, particularly with drop boxes, there’s no reason for that to be in the process,” Jones said. “You’ve got three weeks of early voting and Saturday voting. You’ve given ample time and opportunities for people to get the effort to go in to vote.”
For Jones and his colleagues, the threat of illegitimate absentee voting outweighs the benefit of greater participation in democracy.
The popularity of absentee voting exploded last year amid the coronavirus pandemic. The voting method typically used by about 5% of voters rose to 26% in the 2020 presidential election.
More Republicans than Democrats voted absentee as recently as the 2018 primary, when voting by mail was often used by older Georgians. In November’s election, almost twice as many Democrats as Republicans returned absentee ballots after President Donald Trump ridiculed them, even though he himself has voted by mail.
Former Republican U.S. House Speaker Newt Gingrich recently wrote that absentee ballot drop boxes “make it harder for Republicans to win,” a claim that Democrats attacked as an acknowledgement that restricting voting is the GOP’s goal rather than fighting fraud.
“Expanding access to voting equals more people voting equals Republicans losing elections,” said state Rep. Bee Nguyen, a Democrat from Atlanta. “It’s the reality in Georgia that for many years we’ve seen more restrictive voting laws get passed, and that means Democrats need to work harder to overcome those restrictive voting laws.”
One of the proposals, backed by the Senate Majority Caucus and Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, would end at-will absentee voting. Under a state law passed by the Republican-controlled General Assembly in 2005, any registered voter is allowed to cast an absentee ballot.
Sixteen states require voters to provide an excuse if they want to vote outside a polling place, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Those excuses can include age, disability, sickness or travel.
House Speaker David Ralston, a Republican from Blue Ridge, said Thursday that he doesn’t support eliminating no-excuse absentee voting.
“It seems like there’s a coordinated effort to limit access to the ballot, and it’s not something we need after so many gains” in voting options last year, said Aunna Dennis, executive director for Common Cause Georgia, a government accountability organization. “We’re definitely going to be on the defensive.”
With majorities in both the state House and Senate, Republicans have the numbers to change voting laws if they decide to do so. Democrats say they might ask the courts to fight rollbacks of what they see as fundamental voting rights.
State Sen. Brandon Beach, a Republican from Alpharetta, said election laws should be the same for everyone and all voters should be required to cast their ballots in person.
Beach heard from a voter who felt her vote was diluted because she had to show photo ID at her polling place but absentee ballots were verified by matching voter signatures.
“She felt disenfranchised,” Beach said. “She felt like she played by one set of rules and the others played by another set of rules, and that’s not fair. We need to have one set of rules for everybody.”
An audit of voter signatures on a sample of 15,000 absentee ballot envelopes, conducted by law enforcement officers with the GBI and secretary of state’s office, found no cases of fraudulent signatures last month.
Still, some voters — such as those in the military and living overseas — can’t show up at the polls and would likely still be allowed to vote remotely under proposed legislation.
Proposed voting restrictions in Georgia
Require an excuse to cast an absentee ballot
Ban absentee ballot drop boxes
Mandate photo ID to be included when returning an absentee ballot
Eliminate mobile voting buses during early voting
Forbid governments and organizations from mailing absentee ballot applications